She came back wrong by Lluvia +18
Responses: 1
Categories: Episode Rewrite, Season 1, Season 2, Season 3, Season 6, Wishverse, Alternate Reality
Characters: Buffy, Ensemble, Spike, Willow

When Buffy is resurrected, she does come wrong. She is a completely different Buffy, in fact, she is an alternative one from a parallel universe.

The alternative Buffy can be:

  • The one from the Wishverse.
  • A Buffy who was never brought back to life after the Master killed her.
  • Or one who was killed during the Acathla’s fight.



  • Whoever version of Buffy you choose, died and went to Heaven.
  • Willow tries to get rid of the Buffy she brought back to have the "right Buffy" back, Spike stops her.
  • Slow-burn Spuffy.
  • Buffy having trouble dealing with the intrusive scoobies.


  • Buffy can be depressed but not self-destructive or abusive.
  • Buffy freaking out at having a sister.


  • The original Buffy can’t be back.


Willow revived Buffy after her jump from the tower. The Buffy that came back...died in the wishverse. 
And wishverse Buffy is happy to see her old ally in Prague
Challenge response 

Categories: Season 6, Wishverse
Characters: Buffy, Spike, Wesley, Willow
Genres: Hurt/Comfort, Resurrection, Romance
Warnings: Attempted Rape, Character Death, Child Abuse, Mental Health Issues, Rape (Implied)
Challenges: She came back wrong
Completed: Yes Chapters: 17 Table of Contents
Word count: 34,015 Hit Count: 10,674 ePub Downloads: 79
Published: December 04, 2022 Updated: February 01, 2023