Comments For Gone Wishing
Please log in or register to comment.
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 15 on June 11, 2021 10:38pm

Haha, I love Anya!  I’m also going to have to look up Westley’s boots, they’re quite the popular fashion accessory!!!  Good story, thanks for sharing!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 14 on June 11, 2021 09:23pm

Ughh…could we get a spell to get Buffy out of her head!  She just keeps over analyzing everything!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 13 on June 11, 2021 05:29pm Liked

That was a heartbreaking chapter!  Buffy was just so sad and desperate for clarity.  She can’t admit things are clear already, she just doesn’t want to see them.  And Spike, lost in the bottle again, eternally love’s bitch!  This line was wonderful:

Sometimes it felt like he’d been in love with her forever, like he’d been made a vampire just so he could live long enough to find her.


[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 12 on June 11, 2021 05:15pm Liked

So glad everyone made it back in one piece!  Love that Dawn is trying so hard for Buffy and Spike to be together.  You’re characterization is spot on across the board!  Anya trying to read her parts in the book over Buffy’s shoulder, perfect!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 11 on June 11, 2021 06:37am Liked

Haha, Clem as the priest!  I can totally picture him doing the whole “marriage…” spiel.  Aww, Spike!  He just wants so desperately to be loved and wanted!  Here’s hoping he gets a good ending back in the real world!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 10 on June 11, 2021 12:47am

So glad Anya and Tara are always there to offer their support to and for Spuffy!  Get on board Xander or get off the tracks!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 9 on June 10, 2021 10:42pm Liked

Andrew is so naive, I love it!!!  The love description and pep talk from Spike was simply wonderful!  Here’s hoping Buffy actually listened!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 8 on June 10, 2021 08:26pm

Ahhh, that’s better, I thoroughly enjoy having Spike worship Buffy, even if she is living in denial land!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 7 on June 10, 2021 07:34pm

A magical, regrowing dress!!!  Poor Buffy, she can’t catch a break, even with her wardrobe!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 6 on June 10, 2021 07:20pm Liked

Ha, I knew it!  Warren is the horrible Rugen!  Perfect casting with that.  Both evil, slimy little worms!!!  I’m a bit confused as to why Spike is so eager to send Buffy on her way.  I know he wants out of this place, but he’s acting like he hates her.  thinking

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 5 on June 09, 2021 06:34pm Liked

Loved that last bit!  I knew there wasn’t going to be much graphic sex in this one since the rating is “R” (I’m trying desperately not to make a pirate joke with that!!!), but having them flip through the seven pages of raunchy sex is almost as good!!

This line broke my heart!!!

He wondered what he’d done to deserve an eternity of loving women who wouldn’t love him back.

Poor Spike!  We all love you here!!!  heart

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 4 on June 09, 2021 06:18pm Liked

Haha I love that this trip barely even tries to fight Spike and then it’s only Anya!!!  Yay, Spike’s almost caught up to her, can’t wait until they’re alone in the swamp together!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 3 on June 09, 2021 06:03pm Liked

That does totally make sense that Anya is Inigo, and that Jonathan is Vizzini (because they were both so short!)!!  haha  Haha Cordellia as a lady in waiting.  I’m surprised she didn’t throw a hissy fit!!

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 2 on June 09, 2021 05:36am Liked

Ohh good lord you’re bringing in the whole crew!?!?  Ughh, does that mean Angel is going to be here?  You should make him Miracle Max!!!  haha

[Report This]
honeygirl51885 commented on Chapter 1 on June 08, 2021 11:43pm Liked

Ohh, this is so much fun!  I just rewatched The Princess Bride yesterday and vaguely recalled a Spuffy fanfic that was set in the verse.  I also just finished OffYourBird’s Dirty Dancing and Demons and was totally craving more movie makeovers!  One search later and here I am!

It’s so good so far!  I love using "Gone” and the ray gun as the premise that lands them in this movie world.  Also, movie ray gun way cooler than invisibility ray gun!  I want one!  I’m obsessed with films!!

Casting Andrew as the narrator, perfect!  And, Dawn as the kid, that interaction is going to be epic!!  Can’t wait to see how Spuffy plays this out!  Also, I’m thinking Warren is going to be either Humperdinck, Vizzini, or Rugen.  I’m going with Rugen since he’s such an asshat!  For some reason I’m seeing Jonathan as Inigo. thinking

Very excited to continue!!

[Report This]
The Danish Bird commented on Chapter 15 on April 04, 2021 07:53am Liked

Apparently, I’ve been missing out on a totally important movie experience according to some...up until yesterday that is. AJMilone told me to go read this fic after I finished The Princess Bride, even though I’m usually not into crossovers, and I’ve got to agree with’s awesome!

I loved how you followed the plot, yet made the Scoobies aware of what movie they were in and what was happening, so we got to see their reactions. Lovely twist that Spike was the only one who had never seen the movie before. And of course Andrew had to be the narrator.

Your ending back in Sunnydale was just perfect. So nice with a supportive Willow as well as Dawn. Locking Buffy out of the house to force her to go to Spike...brilliant, haha.

Thank for sharing...even though I know it’s a long time ago.

Author's Response on May 23, 2021 08:32am

Aww I'm glad you got to experience the magic od The Princess Bride and doubly glad you enjoyed this fic! I saw the movie so many times growing up I can practically recite it from memory, and making it Spuffy was so much fun. Andrew is a delight to write haha, I'm glad you liked him. Thanks so much for reading! 

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 15 on March 30, 2021 02:43am Liked

I want to be like Sisley and Ebert and say something like, “a semi-existential romp, touching on piracy, sword play, politics, torture and true love. Two thumbs up!”


[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 10 on March 30, 2021 01:46am Liked

Angel touched his hair again, scowling, and then was suddenly gone.

Why oh why didn’t someone get to hit him?? Ugh. 

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 9 on March 30, 2021 01:40am Liked

Hahaha the Dawn/Andrew banter! Also this is a lot of healthy sweetness with spuffy

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 8 on March 30, 2021 12:15am Liked

Andrew looked up guiltily. “Sorry! I didn’t…they were talking about board games! It was confusing!”

Your Andrew voice is absolutely perfect, and I’m loving the interactions between Andrew and Dawn. Both of them are surprisingly innocent here and in canon.

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 6 on March 30, 2021 12:02am Liked

Buffy scowled. “I hate horses.” She let out a little shriek and clutched Wesley as one of the guards led their horse away by the reins like a child’s pony ride. Spike smirked. At least he managed to ride his own horse. Stupid poncy King.

Howling! Plus Angel as the albino 🤣

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 5 on March 29, 2021 11:55pm Liked

“Whoa.” Dawn’s eyes were wide as Andrew stopped reading and cleared his throat. “I don’t remember this part.”

“Um,” Andrew squirmed a little in his chair. “Maybe we should skip ahead.”

Dying here 😂 All that page flipping 🤣🤣🤣

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 4 on March 29, 2021 11:48pm Liked

This is ridiculous, fluffy, campy fun. Actually not too far off from both The Princess Bride and BtVS 😂 perfect combination!

[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 3 on March 29, 2021 11:42pm Liked


[Report This]
bmerb commented on Chapter 1 on March 29, 2021 09:46pm Liked

Oh. My. Gawds. I’m ridiculously excited to have found this. *clapping and squealing with glee*

[Report This]
Loverofspike78 commented on Chapter 1 on February 03, 2021 02:21am Liked

Holy wow, I was laughing so hard this whole chapter! Thank you so much for that.  This month has been the worst of my life with my mom passing unexpectedly and I haven't had much to smile about. Just wanted to let you know that your story helped me forget to be sad for a little while🙂

Author's Response on February 05, 2021 08:01am

I'm so sorry to hear about your mom and I'm sending you all the love. hugI'm glad I gave you a reason to smile, thank you for the super lovely comment!

[Report This]
Dynamite commented on Chapter 15 on January 20, 2021 12:30pm Liked

Two of my favorite things combined, I loved this so much! This might be my favorite cross-over/AU. Such a light hearted good time, with a Spuffy ending that totally fit the characters. I love Dawn so much in this! 

Author's Response on February 05, 2021 08:00am

I really enjoy writing Dawn, so thank you so much! I'm glad you liked it <3

[Report This]
PRationality commented on Chapter 15 on January 18, 2021 09:44pm Liked

What glorious fun! A great send up for the movie and our Sunnydale friends!

[Report This]
DragonflyLady commented on Chapter 15 on April 20, 2020 04:24am Liked

Sorry, I was too busy reading, no, devouring your story since all the chapters were one after the other and I didn't review until the end.

Loved it. A lot.

Author's Response on April 28, 2020 07:24am

I appreciate any comments!! Thank you so much I'm thrilled you liked it. heart

[Report This]
Angelsheart1 commented on Chapter 15 on December 25, 2019 07:30am Liked

Great story!  Loved reading it!

Author's Response on December 31, 2019 09:35pm

Thank you so much! 

[Report This]
Please log in or register to comment.