"There's a new sheriff in town." by JustWriter +11
Responses: 0
Categories: Alternate Reality, Season 2, Crossover (Books or TV shows outside Buffyverse)
Characters: Buffy, Ensemble, Mayor Richard Wilkins III, Other, Principal Snyder, Spike, Willy the Snitch
Summary:

My absolute favorite tv show ever is about Jack Carter, a U.S. Marshal who stumbles into a top secret town in the middle of nowhere and, due to his out of the box thinking, saves the town and the universe and is subsequently hired on as Sheriff.

Now, my challenge is this:  Sunnydale gets a new Sheriff and instead of becoming the stereotypical Sunnydale adult, he actually tries and succeeds at making a difference, without spilling town secrets to those not in-the-know of course, and becomes someone people can count on, despite being flawed, and through amazing luck has not been killed off by accident or by the mayor's goons.

You don't need to use Jack from EUReKA (Sci-Fi/SyFy), but if you do, then perhaps Buffy reminds him of his own daughter Zoe and he's not as ready to believe she's just some delinquent. And, since it's that kind of show, maybe this Jack Carter was displaced from his own timeline or universe and his family doesn't exist here because his counterpart died when his high school sweetheart crashed his car. I'm open to him being paired with any of the amazing women from BtVS or Angel (as long as they're legal aged and not Buffy).